Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

In re Ashley Madison Customer Data Security Breach Litigation

United States District Court, E.D. Missouri, Eastern Division

August 24, 2016




         This matter is before the Court on Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Discovery Directed to the Avid Defendants. (Doc. No. 207) The motion is fully briefed and ready for disposition. For the following reasons, the motion will be granted in part.

         Based upon the parties' joint proposed scheduling plan for limited discovery and briefing related to Defendants' contemplated motion to stay and compel arbitration (Doc. No. 182), on July 1, 2016, the Court entered a scheduling order for written discovery reasonably necessary to address the issues likely to be raised in Defendants' contemplated motion (Doc. No. 189). The parties disagree on the scope of that discovery.

         Plaintiffs contend the purpose of the pending discovery is to explore all evidence probative of whether Plaintiffs entered into a binding agreement to arbitrate their claims, a fact-intensive determination. To that end, Plaintiffs seek to discover the exact nature of the sign-up, sign-on, and purchase processes as they existed during the relevant time periods, the exact layout and sequence of pages through which a Plaintiff progressed as he Dated:to and later used the Ashley Madison website, exactly how the terms and conditions were presented and displayed (if at all) during each step, exactly what the website required a Plaintiff to do in order to manifest assent to terms and conditions (and when), whether that step was actually required by website design or could be circumvented, whether and how Defendants collected data evidencing any Plaintiffs' alleged assent, how the website was designed to ensure knowing assent, and whether and how Defendants notified a Plaintiff of changes in the terms and conditions. Plaintiffs have agreed to limit the scope of most of their requests to the 18 named Plaintiffs, as opposed to all Ashley Madison users, which the Court finds appropriate since no class has been certified at this point.[1]

         Defendants object to Plaintiffs' discovery requests on the grounds that they seek documents and information that exceed the “limited discovery” ordered by the Court. Defendants take the position that only discovery regarding the registration process and clickwrap agreement is necessary to address their arbitration motion, citing Burcham v. Expedia, No. 4:07CV1963 CDP, 2009 WL 586513 (E.D. Mo. Mar. 6, 2009). To that end, Defendants have produced screen shots of the sign up pages Plaintiffs were required to complete to create an account and the dates on or about which each version appeared on the website; images of “dialog boxes” by which certain Plaintiffs allegedly confirmed their agreement to the updated Terms and Conditions and the dates of which they so agreed; copies of the Ashley Madison homepage as it appeared on or about the dates on which each produced version of the Terms and Conditions appeared on the website; and each version of the Terms and Conditions posted on the website through July 20, 2015 and the time period each version was available on the website. Defendants also produced Comma-Separated Values (CSV) data with associated text files apparently containing information about Plaintiffs' account profiles and activities on the website, but without any explanation of the origin of the data or how it was generated, what the entries mean, or which of Plaintiffs' discovery requests each data file purports to respond to.

         Upon review, the Court finds Defendants' discovery responses incomplete. Whether Plaintiffs will be permitted to proceed with this class action, or instead be compelled to individually arbitrate their claims, is a significant enough issue that Plaintiffs are entitled to full and complete discovery on the question of arbitrability as it relates to the 18 named Plaintiffs during the time period they were accessing the Ashley Madison web site.[2] Specifically, Plaintiffs are entitled to:

• exemplars of each version of the Ashley Madison home page or application screen displayed to them when they first accessed the Ashley Madison website;
• exemplars of each version of the complete sequence of any Ashley Madison web pages, application screens, or other user interfaces accessed by Plaintiffs to enroll in, log into, and make purchases on the site;
• exemplars of each version of any Ashley Madison web pages or application screens or other user interfaces that required Plaintiffs to affirmatively acknowledge awareness of or agreement to the Terms and Conditions before further utilizing the Ashley Madison website;
• documents sufficient to identify the time period(s) each such version was active/live on the site, and show the differences between any such versions;
• web server logs or other documents that demonstrate whether any Plaintiff actually viewed web pages, including Terms and Conditions, or whether any record was made of any Plaintiff manifesting assent to any Term; and
• individualized data relating to Plaintiffs' use of the Ashley Madison website in a standardized file format that corresponds to Plaintiffs' specific requests.

         The Court notes Defendants have already identified the name (provided by Plaintiffs), username, account number, date the account was created, and date of last log in for Ashley Madison accounts created by Plaintiffs. (See Response to Interrogatory No. 2, Doc. No. 208)

         Should Plaintiffs contend that a Rule 30(b)(6) deposition remains necessary after Defendants have fully responded and produced all documents responsive to their discovery requests, then ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.